? ,
: <<
? ?
?
? ?>>
. -,
. . ,
,
[-5].
.
, ( )
. . . ,
, .
. . , 1907-1941 .
,
,
,
, , . .
.
,
, .
, , ,
.
, .
, -
.
,
.
,
,
.
( )
: ,
, . . ,
.
: ?
(. . ,
. , . .) ,
.
? , << , >>.
.
- , . .
: - ?
, ,
-, . , .
""
, ,
.
: .
:
.
,
,
,
"" .
. ,
.
"" . , ,
, ,
.
, ,
.
, ,
" ". :
? ""
, , ( )
"" .
.
, " " (,
,
. .), - .
"" . ,
.
, - ,
. .
, ,
, .
: , ( )
, ,
, .
,
,
.
.
,
,
,
. .
.
1) . . ..
- ., 1907.
.
"" ... ,
, .. ( ).
. . [-5].
1925
1) .. "
" // , 1925, No.1, .157-175.
. .
. .. - "
" // , 1925, No.4,
.133-143, - ...
1928
1) . <<
"">>. "" 13 1928 .
. ..
"" . ..
<<
.
"">>. -
"" ..
..,
.
2) . " ".
"" 27 1928 .
. .
: << , ,
""
...
.
. ,
- , - .
,
. , ,
.
,
""! ,
... , .
- -
>>
1929
1) . " " 18
1929 .
. ..
"".
1975
1) . " " // , 1975, No.1.,
.203-210.
. ...
.
------------------------------------------------------------------
1977
1) .. " ".
- "", 1977 , No.10, .106-114.
. "
" .
, ,
. . -
. : << , ""
,
... ""
.
...>> (.114). -, -
, 1974
. ,
1980 .
- ,
(29 1981 ), .
, ..,
... ..
"
" ..
: <<29 1981 . .
- , ..
...
,
.". (8
1984 ).
-. ..
... ..
,
.
.
..
1) .., .. << "
" >>
// , 1982, No.1, .171-195.
. .
2) .., .. <<
" ">> // , 1982, No.8, .70-82.
. .
3) "- ?".
"", No.39 (716), 25
1982 .
. .
4) " - ".
"", No.41 (718),
9 1982 .
. .
1) . << "-
">>.
"", No.10 (739), 5 1983 .
. - ,
. .
, " "
,
.
.
2) .., .. << "
" >> // ,
1983, No.12, .68-83.
.
" " " ",
,
[-1], [-3], [-5].
. .
" " . .. ..,
, : " ( - .) ,
,
" ( , 1982, No.8).
-, ,
.
, " "
. :
<< ...
.
,
.
.
>>.
3) . ( , ....). "
- ". - " - ", 1983 ,
.26-28.
. ,
... .
.. " ,
" (.27).
4) . " ..." // "
", No.4, .28-32.
. .
5) . " ?" // , 1983,
No.9, .84.
. .
6) . " - " // "
", 1983, No.8, .28-30.
. .
7) ... " - , ". -
"", 19 1983 .
. - , ..
"". : ",
,
...
, .
. :
,
. - !"
8) .. " ..". -
"" ( , ), 15 1983 .,
124. ,
-
...
.
.
9 1984 (.
18) "
"
.
. ,
.., ...
..
.. : << ,
..,
,
,
. , "
"
, ,
- -
>> (8 1984 ).
1) " ", 1984 , No.1,
, , ,
.
" .....
.
, , ,
,
- " (.115).
"..
,
. , ,
- "
(.116).
".. ,
,
,
, ,
,
, " (.119).
2) .. << ..
"-" >> //
, 1984, No.2, .114-125.
. .
.
1) . "
". - ., 1985.
. , , ,
.7-8.
.
2) .. " 400 ". - "
", 2 1985 .
. , ,
,
( ) ...
3) .. " ". - "
", No.51 (1021), 20 1985 .
. ..
, .
..
. .
1) .. "
XXVII ". - "", 1986, No.1,
.95-107.
. 105 -
. - , .
. : << ""
>> (.105).
2) . " ". - "
", 5 1986 , No.6(5072).
. . ,
" ",
.. .
3) .. " , " //
, 1986, No.5. .66-74.
. . -
. .
. [-5], .149.
1) .., .. << ""
>> // ,
1987, .294, No.2, .310-313.
.
" ".
. .. ..
.
, "
",
. : ..,
.., .. "
", ,
1989, .307, No.4, c.829-832, [-1], [-3].
1) .. " :
" // ,
, . ...
- . ., , 1988,
.167-186.
. ..
.,
" ".
.. :
.., .., ... ,
"" :
". - - . ,
"", 1994, .142-163.
1) .., .. <<
"" (
)>> // ,
, . ...
- . ., , 1989,
.175-192.
. .
[-1], [-3]
.
1) .. . - ., , 1990.
. ,
., .
- " " (.409-412) "
?" (.412-415). ..
. . [-5].
1) ... " ". //
"", No.7, 1991 .
. ,
. 1991
"".
:
<<
, ( )
" ".
,
1992 .
23 1992
...
:
1.
"" "".
,
, .
2. ,
...
3. -
, (,
, ).
4. ( )
" ".
5. .
.
. ,
1925 " " 1
.. ...
, 4 " "
..,
, >>.
.., .., ... 24 1992
.
"" .
1) . " . (
)". - , - "", "PUICO", 1992.
. - , 350
. . 163-164
. ,
. .
, .
,
.
. . ,
. ,
. ,
,
. .
!
. -
" " .
, . . ,
, ""
". , .
, .
. .: " ,
, - .
. ,
,
. ,
,
...
..." (.164). "
" . . ,
""
,
.
1) .., .. <<
(
"")>>. - .
... - . - ,
"", 1994, .164-180.
. .
, :
.., .., ... ,
"" :
". - - . ,
"", 1994, .142-163.
1) (Peter H.Richter)
NACHRICHTEN DER OLBERS-GESELLSCHAFT,
Bremen, April 1995, No.169, .20-21, [-3]:
"Geometrical and Statistical Methods of Analysis of Star
Configurations. Dating Ptolemy's Almagest". A.T.Fomenko,
V.V.Kalashnikiv, G.V.Nosovsky. - CRC Press, USA, 1993.
. .
2) (Peter H.Richter)
NACHRICHTEN DER OLBERS-GESELLSCHAFT,
Bremen, April 1995, No.169, .20-21, [-4]:
Fomenko A.T. Empirico-Statistical Analysis of Narrative
Material and its Applications to Historical Dating.
Kluwer Academic Publishers. The Netherlands. 1994.
. .
3)
(Herbert Illig) "ZEITENSPRUNGE",
Interdisziplinares Bulletin, N.2/95, April 1995, .104-120.
: "Fomenko - der Grosse, statistische Wurf?" -
Rezention und Standortbestimmung von Heribert Illig.
. .
4) .. ".. ".
"" ( , ), 2 1995
, N.59.
. .
5) " - ?" - "
", No.4, 1995 .
. - ...
- .
, , -
.
6) . " ". - "
", 13 1995 , No.37(5568).
. ,
.
7) . "
". - "", 31 1995
.
. ,
.
8) . " ". -
" ", 17 1995 .
. ,
.
1) . " ,
- . - " ", No.4,
23 1996 .
. ,
.
2) .. " ...".
" ", 12 1996 , N1 (1636).
. [-6].
3) .. " ".
" ", N.4(1639), 2 1996 .
. .
4) .. " ..".
" ", N.6, 1996 .
. - ..
, . : " ,
, , :
..."
5) . " .
?" - "
", 3 1996 .
. ,
.
6) ... " ?!" -
"", , 1996,
No.7.
. ,
.
7) . " ". -
"", No.4, 1996, .68-72.
. ,
.
8) . "- - ...
?" - "", No.4, 1996, .73-77.
. ,
.
9) . !
. - "", 1996, No.5. .10-16.
. .
.
: "
..."
10) . " ?" -
"", 14 1996 , .54.
. . : "
, ".
.
11) . "
?" - "", No.7, 1996, .66-72.
. ,
.
12) .. (..).
- . " ",
N.18, 1996 , .116-126.
. . .
.
: <<
: ,
- .
"" >>.
"" ,
[-1] [-5].
13) .. (..).
... -
. " ", N.18, 1996
, .127-154.
. ,
. .
. ""
""
, .
"".
. ,
. ,
, .
..
"". ,
.. ,
. , 1997 ..,
,
.. " ",
31 1997 . . .
..
. "
", , 20 1997 , .179-180.
.
14) . " ... ". -
"", 1996 , No.29(445).
. ,
.
15) . " ". -
"", No.8, 1996, .65-70.
. ,
.
16) . " , ". -
" ", 29 1996 , No.94(1179).
. . : ", !
...
..." .
17) . " ". -
" ", 27 1996 .
. ,
.
18) . " ,
". - "", No.10, 1996, .66-71.
. ,
.
19) . "
- ". - " ", 30
1996 , No.44 (5626).
.
"", .
20) . " ". -
"", No.11, 1996, .72-77.
. ,
.
21) . " ". -
" ", 22 1996 , No.47(1763).
. , ,
,
. . ,
.
( - ).
22) . " - ". -
"", 1996 .
. ,
.
23) . " ". -
"", No.12, 1996, .66-70.
. ,
.
24) . << .
" "
>>. - "", 21 1996
.
. .
. , , .
25) .., ...
. . - , , "",
1996.
. -
... .
. ,
, ,
,
" ". , 1998
: ., ., "
, ", ., +, 1998,
., ., "
", ., +, 1998.
1) . " :
". - "", 29 1997 .
. .
. , "",
. .
2) . "". - "-
", 5 1997 .
. .
.
3) . " ". -
"", No.1, . 68-73.
. ,
.
4) ... << "
..">>. -
" ", No.20, 1997 , .181-184.
. . .. ,
, 18- .
,
, 20 . -,
...
, ,
.
" ", N.22,
1998 , .240-257.
, ..
,
. ,
...
.. : " ,
,
,
, .
,
, ,
, ..." ( "
", 31 1997 ).
.. , ,
. ",
,
, , ,
: ,
". .
5) ... " ". "",
1997, No.2, .70-74.
. .
. .
, .
, , .
- .
6)
"" .. " ,
?" (.75-76). .
.. .
,
"".
. , ,
"". ,
..
.. ( ).
.. ,
,
. ,
. ,
, .
,
" ".
, ,
. , "
" . , ,
.. ,
.
, "" 1991
" "
.
, .
(. 1991 ).
.. "" 1997.
" -".
. ,
. .
7) . " , ".
" ", 21 1997 , No.20(5653).
. .
8) . " ". "
", . 4179 19-15
1997 .
. ,
. .
, , ..
(. ).
9) . " ".
, 11 1997 , 23(5656).
. . : ",
, ! ..."
, .
10) ( " "). "
". , 7 1997
.
. .
(),
"300- "
.
( ),
, . -
, ,
.
11) . " ?" -
"", No.1, , 1997 , .53-55.
. .
.
12) << "" >>.
" ", 1997, No.30-32 (320-322), .14.
.
. , .
""
(29.01.97).
13) . " ".
.. " ", No.44(889), 1997
., .19.
.
, . , .
, ,
"- ". ..
. ,
,
- .
14) ... " (
)". - " ", - 1997
., 3, .87-95.
. .
"",
... (.
).
15) ... <<"" >>. -
" ", - 1997 ., 3,
.95-101.
. .
"". (.
).
16) . <<"" >>. -
"", No.6, 1997, .74-79.
. .
.
17) . << "" >>. -
"", No.7, 1997, .74-79.
. .
.
18) . " ".
- "", No.8, 1997, .67-71.
. .
.
19) . ", . , ,
". - "". - "-", ,
"", -, - "", , 1997.
. - .
. "",
. ( )
"". .
.
, ..
, .
.,
- - .
.
20) . " - !" - "",
No.52(213), 1997 , .5.
. , .
.
21) , . ", .
( 945 )". -
" ", 31 1997 , .5.
. , ,
.
- ..
... ..
.
22) ... << " ">>. -
1998 . ...
, , 1997, .296-303.
. . .
"", (. ).
.
, , .
, , .
" " , ,
.
... .
! "" -
: " X
?!" (.297). : " " (.301).
..
,
, , : " - ,
, " (.303). : "...
... ,
, ,
" (.303). ,
"" " ".
- , -
"
",
... , ..
(1987 ., 294, No.2, .310-313),
"", ,
.
" ".
23) . " ". (
). - , , - "", 1997.
. - 300 .
,
(. ).
,
,
- .
,
.
. ,
, ,
.
.
24) .. " - ..".
"" ( , ), 6 1997 .
.
, , -
.. ( ).
25) ... " ". -
" ", 1997, No.11, .30-37 ( ); 1997, No.12,
.10-17 ( ).
. ,
. '
, -.
. , -
, - ,
.
"" .
.. ,
... , ..,
, : ", , -
.., , ,
" (No.12, .33). ""
. , .. ,
"" "",
,
. ,
"" . , ""
, , , ,
" ". ,
.
. , "" ,
, - ,
.
.
, ,
.
.
. ..
. ,
""
, "
" (No.12,
.34). . ,
.. . -
- " ".
"" .
, ,
. ..
.
.. ,
.
. :
. , , .
, , , ,
, .
, , IV XIV .
, " ".
: ""
. .
, - , -
,
" " . , ,
"", .. , ,
"" . , - ,
, - , , "
" . ""
. .
"
", .
..
. ,
.. , , ,
. ",
, :
-
(, , , ),
" (No.12, .35).
, , , -
.
" ".
26) . " ". - "", No.12,
1997, .68-71.
. .
.
27) ... " ". .
" ", 2, 1997, .9-13.
. .
, " ".
. , ..
. 1987
"", ,
.
(. ). ,
.. .
.
28) . " ". " ".
: 18 1997 .
. .
29) " - ". "", .
: 25 1997 . .
. ,
.
30) .. " ". " ",
. "", , 1997 .
: 8 1997 .
. .
31) . "
". "", .
: 1997, 10.09.
. , .
. : "
- , -
,
".
32) . " ". "
", . :
1997. 05.18.
. . , ,
,
. " , -
, . ,
. ,
".
33) . " ". TV Review,
No.72, 13/11/1977. Canadian-Russian Biweekly Publication.
.
, " ", 3
1996 . . . ,
.
1998
1) . " . -
" - "", No.1, 1998, .68-71.
( 12- 1997 .)
. .
.
2) . " " -
"", No.2, 1998, .73-76.
. .
.
3) . " " -
"", No.3, 1998, .73-75.
. - ,
1 "" 1998 .
. .
4) " ". - "", 13-17
1998 ., .. ( -
" ", ).
.
...
"", No.8(221), 1998 .
" . (
() ..)".
"
", 1998 , No.3.
, "",
" ", No.24-26, 1998.
. , .
.
.
"" , ""
" ...". ,
. : " ,
,
,
- , ".
: "
...".
? ,
.
5) , " ". "
", 20 1998 ., 8, .10.
. .
.
6) , " ".
"", 10 1998 , .50-53.
. .
.
7) .., .., .., ... "
. (, , )". , - , 1998.
.
. ,
.
. ,
.
8) . " ?
: ". - "", 19, No.7, 1998,
3.
. , .
9) , " ". - " ",
1998, No.3, .165-188.
. .
.
, ,
. .
10) . " ". " ",
No.14(244), 9-15 1998 .
. , " ",
. . ,
- ,
. . , "
".
11) ... << " ">>.
" ", No.22,
1998, .230-239.
.
, .
. - .
12) ... " ".
" ", No.22,
1998, .258-267.
. . ,
,
.
.. -
.
13) .. " ". .. " ". -
"", No.14(99), 14 1998 ., .4.
. - -
., "" 10 1998
. ...
- .
. ,
.
.. .. ..
.. ,
"".
14) . "
". - "",
, ., . 23,
1998, .30-33.
. . ..,
,
"" .
15) ... " ,
". , <<
" ", 1998, No.2.
... -,
>>.
. ,
- . -.
: ", (.. - .)
. - , , ,
".
16) . " ...
?!". " ", 28 1998 .No.62[11651].
. .
, ..
.., .
, "
,
".
17) .. << " ">>.
"-", 1998, No.4.
. .
, "-" 1997 , No.10.
. ,
. ,
.
"-" .
, , ,
.
18) .. " ".
"-" , 1998, No.4.
. - .. ,
. ,
- <<""
, ,
>>.
19) .. "". "-", 1998, No.4.
. - .. ,
. ,
.
20) . "", .
: 13 1998 .
. . ,
.
"" (. ).
21) . " . .
". "", .
: 11 1998 .
. , .
22) . " ?". " & ", ,
.
. , .
23) . "
". " ", .
: 20 1998 .
. .
24) .. " ". " ",
. :
1998.01.14.
. , .
25) .. " ". " ", .
: 1998.02.05.
. , .
, , : " ,
, , , ,
, .
-
".
26) . " ".
"- ", .
: 1998.13.06.
.
"- ". ,
" ".
27) . " , -
?" . - "", 11
1998 .
. .. - , .
. .
" ". ..,
"
...".
28) . " ?" -
"", No.23(473), 30 - 5 1998 .
. ,
.
29) . "- - ...
?". - " ", 1998 .
. ,
. ., .,
., . " ".
30) . << "">>. - "
", No.5, 1998 .
. ,
. ., .,
., . " ".
31) ... << " ">>. - ,
No.1(11), 1998, c.37-42.
. ...
,
.
32) "",
1998 . .
33) " ",
1998 . .
34) " ", 1998 .
" "
. .
" -" ( ),
" ( -)
". "" .
: " , ,
, (
".
35) ., ., .. "
". - , - "", 1998.
. ,
.
.
.
36) .. " ". - "", 24
1998 .
. .
. ""
(No.106, 11.06.1998). . ,
, .
.
37) " - ?" - "",
No.29-30 (479-480) 11-24 1998 .
. - ( )
, 22 1998 .
No.4. <<: 26 , 5
, 5 - . : "
" ( . )>>.
.
- ..
:
1) .., ..., (),
2) .., .-. (),
3) .., ..-.., (),
4) - .., (),
5) .., .-. ( ),
6) .., ..., (),
7) .., (),
8) .., ().
: ..,
.., - ..,
- .., - ..;
.., .., ..,
..; ... .., .., ..
: ... .. (), .. (),
.. (), .. (), .. (),
.. ().
,
. , .
, " " ..
, ,
:
"
,
".
,
, -
? "" - - -,
"" - -. "
", (,
?),
,
.
, -
. ,
- . ,
: "
, .. ".
, "
" ..
26 1998 .
.
38) "". - " ", N0.29-30,
1998.
.
, .
... ,
, " "
, -
.
.
.
39) . . -
" ", 31, ..
. - .
, .
40) . " ". -
" ", No.15,16(61,62), 1998 , .15.
. .
, ..
.., ..
.., " ",
. . .
41) . " ?" -
"", 11 1998 .
. .
. " "
28 1998 . .
. ..
, " ".
42) . " ?
". - "", 12-18 1998 , .12.
. . -
- , ,
. ,
, "-
, ,
".
,
.
43) , . <<"" -
. . :
!>>.
. ,
, -
, , , "
". :
" ", << - "
">>, " ", " ?".
.
. : "
, ,
, , ,
, ...".
.
44) " ", ( ?) 1998 .
, - ,
. .
45) " ", 31 1998 .
" ",
, , -
, "", ...
,
.
46) ...
(IX-XII .). . - , , 1998.
.
.
" " ( ).
1 << "
">>, .289-313,
.
..
- .
. ,
. .
.. : " 8 2 3
( ) 0 ( )" (.289).
.
47) . ,
1998, 68, No.8, "", "". . 683,
,
"
..,
. ".
48) . " ". "
", 19 1998 .
. ,
-
.. " ". .. ,
" ".
49) ... " .
". - " ", 3, -. , ,
1998, .3-25.
. ..
.
. ,
. ..
: " ,
. Cum tacent, clamant. [,
1997] ..." (.17). ,
-
, , ,
,
..
.
, .. ""
: " , , -
" (.17).
50) .., .. (
). "
". -
- " : , ,
, ". , 1998, .156-158.
,
( ), .
.
-
.
51) . " .
, ". - "
", "Ex libris ", 4 1998 , .7.
. ,
, , ..
. ,
. .
1) . " ". "",
1,2, .27-31, 3, .34-37, 1999 .
. ,
..,
"" . : "
. ,
,
. ,
, , ...
, , .
. ,
. ,
, ".
..
,
"". "" 36
3, " -
".
2) . " : -
". "", 3, 1999 , .38-39.
.
.., , - ,
.
"".
3) . " - ".
" ", 15 1999 .
. - , - ,
.
: "
, ,
. .
". , .
22 1998 ,
.
.. ,
-. .
. , ,
, ,
,
. , .,
" ".
4) . " ".
"", 9, 1999 , .26-27.
. , ,
. .
. , , ,
, " " (.27), ,
(.27).
: " , -
!"
5) . " ". " "
13 1999 .
. .
, , : "
". . :
<< : " - ", " -
", ,
>>.
---------------------------------------------------------------
1999 , "", -,
"" ,
. : ., ., "
", "", 2, 1999 ,
.143-158.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
,
, . ,
.
Internet'.
, ,
.
.
---------------------------------------------------------------
( ).
..
" ", No.18, .127-154, 1996 .,
.
"" [-3],[-3]
.
,
, .
1. .. , ""
- " ",
VII .. (.129).
.
"" " "
[-3], .180. : " ,
,
600 .. 1300 .."
2. ..: " ..,
, , " (.129).
.. " ".
.
3. .139 ..
-
. ,
.. . ,
[-3] ,
.
4. ..
, :
. , ..
, -
, ,
. ,
, ,
.
. , ,
( -
)
.
, .
.. .
. , ..
(.146).
5. .144-145 .. ,
,
. ,
. ,
, , ,
, .
6. .148-149 .. ,
,
, ,
.
[-3],
( ).
4
. ,
, ,
.
[-3],
.
----------------------------------------------------------------
( 1997 .)
17 "" 29 1997
,
. ,
: " ",
. ,
.
"
,
, 50-
".
,
(
). , ,
- ,
..
. ,
" ",
. - ,
.
(
),
.
1970- . 1990
.
- . ,
20 ,
, , .
" "
,
"". , ,
,
, ,
. ,
600 1300 .
""
. ,
""
.
" " .
,
. , -
.
. .,
.
XVI-XVII ,
, . ,
,
.
,
"",
. ,
, .
,
. , ,
-
. , .
-. ,
,
.
.
" ",
.?
- " ",
" " "
" ..,
,
. -
.
., ., ,
""
, . . (
.), ?
. ,
, ""
, ,
. - , .
"" ,
.
" " .
.
"", 1987
, ( 294, 2).
! , .
. - 200
, , -
1000-1500 .
.. ,
, ""
.. XVI .
!
, . ""
( ""
- 200 ) ""
""
!
, . "",
, , 1 , 1 .. "", -
- ,
.
, .
. .., ..
.. "
" ( , 307, 4 1989 ).
.., .. ..
" " (
"" 1991 ;
1995 , - 1993; ,
,
"" ). , ,
,
, . -
"".
. .
. "
",
"",
,
- " ."
" ".
. "", ,
(.? .?)
, .
" ",
.
( , ), ,
(
), 8- ,
.
. , ,
,
.
,
.. .. "
, "
( 1995 1996 ), ..
" " (1996
), .. .. ".
. , , , , ."
(1996 ), .. "
. " (1996 ).
---------------------------------------------------------------
( , )
" "
( " " 1998 .
)
!
" "
. " ",
- .
, - " "
, ,
.
" "
.. .
, ( .),
, ,
. - .
, (1902
.) .
,
.
?
?
""
? .., ..
. ,
X-XVI .
" ". "
"
. ,
., ,
" -
" .
, ..
. ,
,
.. ?!
,
, , .
, ""
., -
.
" " (
!)
. , , !
( .) ,
" "!
, " " 1956
, " "!
" " "" !
- .
- .
().
, .
( ,
, - ) -
(). -
. . !
, ,
, ,
.
?!
, " "
.
. , . .
.
() .
,
,
", ".
, - .
, .
.
, - , "".
, , ,
. ,
-
, , , .
,
.. . .
, , '".
, ..
- . , "
" "
" ( , ,
!), - ,
, , .
""
, ,
.
,
, ,
XX ?!
.
..?
,
- XIII-XIV ?
, .. ? ,
,
? ,
, - ?
- XII-XIV .
- . ,
, ,
. -
, .. . .
. .
, ..
1974 ,
,
" ". . ,
XX . - ?
.
, ., .
. " ".
, ,
,
, .
., ,
, , XX
, - ! .
, "",
, 1933 ,
.. " "
!
,
(), ,
. ?
- ?
" " ,
? ,
-, , "
"
(). " "
?
. "
" .
.
, , . -
,
,
- .
,
Last-modified: Fri, 19 Nov 1999 07:34:15 GMT